Bread And Butter Pickles
The garden is starting to produce recently and if your cucumber crop is like mine you are overrun with cucumbers!! So it is time to make pickles. I happened upon this recipe a few years ago and haven’t looked back. These are a bread and butter pickles instead of a deli style dill pickle. A little side note. These are the ONLY pickles my sister will eat.
Here are your basic ingredients:
- Mrs. Wages Bread and Butter Pickle mix. I found mine at Walmart. For some reason my grocery store doesn’t carry this mix.
- White Vinegar. Get the big bottle.
- Sugar. Grab a 5 lb bag.
- Cucumbers.
The recipe calls for 9-11 lbs of cucumbers. I have never weighed my cucumbers. I just get a large amount from the garden and go to town.
Measure out 7 cups of sugar. Yes you read that correctly. SEVEN cups of sugar. This is where the SWEET part of the bread and butter pickle comes.
Add the seasoning packet.
Add in 6 3/4 cups of white vinegar.
Stir.
Put on the stove to boil. I would suggest stirring the mixture till the sugar is all but dissolved then let it come to a boil.
Meanwhile cut your cucumbers. I like mine on the thicker side so they still have a bit of crunch after pickling.
Now it is time to pack your sterilized jars. (For further instructions on sterilizing jars and other great canning instructions check out PickYourOwn.org They explain it so much better than I ever could.) When I say pack I MEAN PACK. Put your back into it. Keep in mind that when the cucumbers are heated up they will shrink a bit so even though you think you have the jar packed as tight as you can there will be extra pickling liquid in the jar in relation to the pickle.
See the jar on the upper left? That is the HUGE cucumber that got out of control in the garden. Turns out it is the exact size of my wide mouth pint jars! Who knew?
Once your cucumbers are packed and your pickling liquid has come to a boil, carefully ladle the pickling liquid into the jars. Be sure to leave head space and remove any air bubbles. Wipe the rim on the jar with a clean wet towel. Add a canning lid, a ring and tighten.
Time to take a bath!!
This little blue jar lifter is a life saver. I won’t tell you how I used to get these jars in and out of the boiling water. It wasn’t safe and I don’t advocate my former method. I didn’t want to spend $6 on a jar lifter. Penny pinching me!! Mom stepped in and gifted me with a jar lifter! Thanks mom. It was well worth it.
Put your jars in a hot water bath for 10 minutes.
Once the 10 minutes is up CAREFULLY remove the jars from the hot water bath. Let the jars sit undisturbed will cooled (12-24 hours) and then remove the rings. You will know if the canning process has processed correctly when the lid does not ‘pop’ or ‘click’ when pressed.
Happy pickling! Let me know if you tried this and how it went. I would love to hear!
originally published July 2011.
Canning Supply List
All the supplies that you will need for water bath canning.
Glass Mason Jar with Lid and Band, Wide Mouth, 32 Ounce, (12Count)
Ball Regular Mouth Pint 16-oz Mason Jar with Lids and Bands (Pack of 24)
(2 Packs) Ball Mason Wide Mouth Half Pint Jars - 8oz - 4 Jars Per Box - Total 8 Jars
More Canning Recipes
Blueberry Syrup
Ready to serve in less than 10 minutes this delicious homemade blueberry syrup can be made with your choice of fresh or frozen blueberries.
Pear Sauce Recipe
Homemade Pear Sauce is just like applesauce but made with fresh pears! Add additional layers of flavor with cinnamon, nutmeg, cardamon and vanilla to personalize your sauce.
Corn Relish Recipe
This corn relish recipe is a delicious combination of corn kernels, red and green bell peppers, celery, onions, vinegar, sugar and spices simmered to marry these fresh flavors together.
Pickled Red Beets
If you are a fan of pickled vegetables, you have to try out my family recipe for homemade pickled beets. With just six ingredients, this simple recipe comes together in less than an hour and is ready for it first tasting in 24 hours. These red beets are perfect for topping on a salad, serving as a side dish or taking to a summer picnic.
Sour Cherry Pie Filling
My easy sour cherry pie filling recipe will have your cooking like your grandma. If you are looking for a homemade cherry pie filling with no cornstarch this is the cherry pie filling for you! This homemade sour cherry pie filling is perfect for cherry pies, cherry tarts, cherry bars and even sneaking a spoonful out of the fridge in the middle of the night.
Seedless Black Raspberry Jam Recipe
This is the best homemade seedless black raspberry jam recipe made with fresh or frozen black raspberries.
Orange Rhubarb Chutney Recipe
Try this rhubarb orange chutney recipe is perfect addition to any charcuterie board this easy chutney recipe is a delicious balance of savory, sweet and spice.
Plum Habanero Salsa Recipe
This homemade habanero salsa recipe is the perfect balance of sweet and heat thanks to the addition of plums.
Blueberry Jam
This is the best homemade blueberry jam recipe made with fresh or frozen blueberries. There is also a low sugar recipe option for this small batch blueberry jam that is equally as delicious.
Easy salsa verde
Easy salsa verde canning recipe and water bath canning instructions. By canning salsa verde you can enjoy your favorite green salsa all year long.
Homemade Tomato Paste
When your garden is overflowing with ripe tomatoes, it is the perfect time to make homemade tomato paste. This tomato paste recipe has only three ingredients and there are two options for storing the tomato paste. Once you know how to make homemade tomato paste, store bought will no longer be an option for you.
Bourbon Cherries
Making bourbon cherries at home is an easy DIY recipe project to stock your bar cart or to give as a hostess gift. I found these to be the best bourbon cherries and everyone always asks for my bourbon cherries recipe. It is up to you how many bourbon soaked cherries you will use to garnish your cocktail. I won't tell!
Strawberry Jam Made With Sure Jell.
One of my favorite ways to preserve fresh strawberries is to make this homemade strawberry jam recipe with sure jell. This is the hot water bath canning method. I use this method because I have more shelf space than freezer space! The canning process is super simple and a great way to try your hand at canning.
Spicy Pickled Banana Peppers
This is the easiest pickled banana peppers recipe. These are the best pickled banana peppers because they are crips, spicy and ready in hours instead of days. Canning crisp banana peppers has never been this quick or this delicious!
Corn Cob Jelly
Use your leftover corn cobs and make old school corn cob jelly. The sweet corn kissed jelly adds a layer of sweet corn flavor to your favorite biscuits, corn bread, pancakes or what ever you like!
Stephen Belyea says
I love bread and butter pickles, but I’ve never tried making them. The only ones I’ve tried are Lady Ashburnham mustard pickles… but surely if I can master those, then I should really stop buying bread and butters and at least TRY to make them!
Thanks for posting a great “how to”
Happy Pickling :-)
Anonymous says
These really are simple! I hope you find that they are as well. Thanks for the comment!
Joffre Vincent Narron says
Sarah – I tell you what……you are great at giving directions. Plus, your enthusiasm is contagious. I love bread & butter pickles. However, Vince is afraid I am “forgetting my way to the kitchen.” But, I actually DO still know where the, uh, the…..you know…..the stove is.
Sending love to all the Mocks!
Martha
Jac Bagis says
I wonder what kinds of seasoning has this bag, here in Brazil does not.