Your Culinary Teacher Since 2008

Comments

    4.83 from 23 votes (20 ratings without comment)

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




  1. Katherine Maher says

    5 stars
    Great recipe I am definitely going to use this for my next pie for thanksgiving. This is Very light and tender crust. Best I have had in years. It is a winner.

    • Sarah Mock says

      Thank you Katherine! That means a lot to me to hear your positive feedback.
      Sarah

  2. Marjorie S. says

    5 stars
    Sarah, I just started making pies because my husband's favorite pie is cherry and he's a vegan. Each time, I have used the food processor and the dough has felt like it was overloaded with Crisco and I didn't know why. Reading your comment about the food processor may make the dough creamy answers my question. I have been looking on line with this problem, but never found any solution to this problem, but you have solved it. Thank you.

    • Sarah Mock says

      I am so glad that my tip helped you figure out the issue! YES! Using a food processor is convenient but it is not always the right tool for the job.

      Sarah

  3. Janet Bullock says

    Sarah, I want to make this piecrust but need to ask a question. In the recipe it says you can make by hand or food processor. In the questions and tips you say it is best not to make it in the food processor. Do you favor the hand method? I would really like to make it in the processor. Thank you

    • Sarah Mock says

      Janet,

      My caution with the food processor is that the food processor has a tendency to cream the fat and the flour together making ball without incorporating all the dry ingredients. If you are able to pulse ON button quickly to cut in the fat and then dump the dough out on the counter to press it together you probably would have success. I just don't want people to turn on the food processor, walk away and then dough be a mess. Let me know how it works out!

      Sarah

      • Carolyn Gipson says

        5 stars
        Excellent pie dough recipe!! very flaky . I did use a food processor. It comes together very quickly do not walk away while processing . I only complaint is getting it in the pie pan. That was almost impossible. I did refrigerate dough for about 2 hours prior to rolling it out. So they are not the prettiest pie shells but they are excellent in taste and texture . Will use again.

      • Sarah Mock says

        Thank you for the comment and the feedback Carolyn! I am wondering if using the food processor (totally your choice!) might have contributed to the trouble in transferring it into the pan. Was the dough super soft? Kind of floppy? Feel free to send me a photo to my inbox if you come across any issues. I might be able to help work you through them.
        Sarah